HLA is pleased to announce the declination of criminal charges against a Pennsylvania pharmacy and owner arising from a $6.5 million inventory shortfall. Following a PBM audit referral to federal prosecutors, the case was resolved civilly by HLA's client for a fraction of the claims paid.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6e47e/6e47e12e08e75d9921f78b07ad4532a0bc15eeb2" alt="PBM audit win"
Federal Prosecutors Encourage PBM Referrals
The President is responsible for appointing a United States Attorney in each federal district and state. The U.S. Attorney serves as the top federal law enforcement official in each state, and reports to the Attorney General of the United States.
Competition exists among U.S. Attorney's Offices for the biggest and most noteworthy cases. In addition, year-after-year, the Department of Justice prioritizes healthcare enforcement given the amount of money involved.
Accordingly, federal prosecutors often cultivate relationships with private industry, including payors and PBMs, to receive investigative "leads." These leads are investigated by the FBI, HHS-OIG, and other federal agents and investigators.
Compounding is an Audit Risk Factor
Compounding is less prolific now, but federal and state agencies remain vigilant to this practice given their experience with compounding schemes and Tricare fraud in years past.
This case involved a PBM audit that noted discrepancies in compound pain creams, and referred the matter for investigation to the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
The Government's Investigation
Following a lengthy investigation, the U.S. Attorney's Office alleged that the Pharmacy, Owner, and business partners had billed Medicare approximately $6.5 million in compound creams even though the pharmacy's records indicated that it had never purchased the APIs in those creams.
In addition, the federal government alleged that Owner had violated laws relating to controlled substances, including Schedule II substances.
HLA's Defense Strategy
Because HLA's founding partner previously served for nearly a decade as an Assistant U.S. Attorney, we understand the risks involved when dealing with the Department of Justice. In this case, we sought to persuade the government that operational errors, not criminal intent, had been the cause of the discrepancy.
Ultimately, the U.S. Attorney's Office agreed with HLA. As a result, Owner was not criminally charged.
Civil Settlement & Resolution
Instead, the U.S. Attorney's Office agreed to resolve the case based on a civil settlement of $2.5 million, a small fraction of the $6.5 million discrepancy at issue. In addition, Owner admitted no wrongdoing, was not excluded, and did not suffer licensing sanctions or professional discipline.
Finally, the settlement resolved all alleged violations of the Controlled Substances Act with no collateral consequences for the Owner.
HLA is Available to Help
If you are facing an aggressive PBM audit with inventory or other discrepancies, call or email before the audit gets referred to law enforcement. If you are the subject of an investigation by law enforcement, we can help stop charges being brought. And if you are the subject of filed criminal charges, we can help resolve the matter before trial or defend your innocence in court.
DEA Announces Three New Rules Expanding Telehealth Access
This article outlines the details of the three new telehealth rules promulgated by the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) and their impact on telehealth providers.
Read More >>Remote Patient Monitoring: Know the Basics of Compliant Billing and Coding
In the article we outline the basics of RPM billing and coding, including which RPM services are billable by payor, the unique fraud risks associated with RPM, and best practices for providers to ensure their billing/coding procedures for RPM services are legally compliant.
Read More >>PBM Audit Alert: Express Scripts Targeting Pharmacies for "Claim Phishing"
Express Scripts is using aggressive audits and investigations to recoup the dollar value of test claims that were never paid. Don't let ESI intimidate you—contact us today for effective audit defense.
Read More >>A Step-by-Step Guide to Securing (and Keeping) Your DEA Registration
Learn how to obtain and protect your DEA registration with our step-by-step guide, updated for 2025 telehealth rules and audit trends—plus proven strategies to resolve denials and maintain compliance. Designed for healthcare providers by legal experts specializing in regulatory defense.
Read More >>